Enrique! I worked with him on a puzzle earlier this year; enjoyable back and forth. Nice to see him nab his NYT debut. POLAR OPPOSITES ...
read moreEnrique! I worked with him on a puzzle earlier this year; enjoyable back and forth. Nice to see him nab his NYT debut. POLAR OPPOSITES is demonstrated in six paired locations, for example, WET in the Northwest (quit it with the it-always-rains-in-Seattle jokes already) and DRY in the SE. Great touch in the oppositional clues, WET as [Like Seattleites who refuse to carry umbrellas even in downpours because it's the principle of the matter] and DRY as [Never like Seattleites ...]
Hey, quit that!
Perimeter puzzles are well-trodden enough that Will Shortz's standards for them are high. Putting a black square in the very NW corner would make Enrique's job much easier since he wouldn't have to find overlapping answers such as WET / WORK. There is a huge universe of antonyms with the same number of letters, but this constraint — in all four corners — adds a huge amount of difficulty.
Typically, it's frowned upon to section off a piece of the grid, so there's only one answer in or out. If you can't figure out KCUP, for example, that bottleneck could mess you up. It does make construction tremendously easier, though, which is especially important in a perimeter puzzle — having WET and WORK cemented into place is a tough constraint. As much as I dislike sectioned corners, I'm okay swallowing that if it means smooth fill, which Enrique mostly delivered.
The other rough aspect of perimeter puzzles is that even if you can get all four corners filled out cleanly, you still have to knit them together in the middle, where your revealer lies. A constructor's nightmare! I like what Enrique did up top, everything clean, and even working in colorful SO TO SPEAK.
Not as much in the south. STELAE might be tough even for a late-week puzzle; crossing it with MOLESKINE could be a killer. Thankfully, I knew the former from crosswords, the latter because I've bought Moleskines for snooty writer friends. (Admit it already, Snooty McSnootfaces.)
All in all, a fine crossword of its genre, exhibiting reasonable trade-offs.