What an enjoyable solve from Elizabeth today. Not a huge amount of overt theme material, so it felt more like a themeless as I was ...
read moreWhat an enjoyable solve from Elizabeth today. Not a huge amount of overt theme material, so it felt more like a themeless as I was going. But what a nice surprise when I sat back to figure out what was really going on. At first I thought it was simply a O representing a dot over each I, but no, it's a full DOT. Very cool!
I personally tried a similar idea a year ago, but I just used Os to "dot" every I. I also wanted to pull off zero extraneous Is or Os (no dot-like Os floating around the grid), so during my solve today I was slightly put off by what felt like me to be superfluous Os — they seemed like orphaned "dots" that didn't belong to any Is. That's my own issue, though.
And the more I thought about my own (failed) experience, I liked the trade-off here. I still think there's a certain inelegance in having an O where there is no matching I (yes, I know, I can be super picky), but I really appreciated the cleanliness of Elizabeth's grid. And Will brings up a good point, that no I is left unDOTted.
That brings us to the revealer. DOTTED I is a brief touch, right to the point. I think DOTTED THE IS (11) or DOTTED ALL THE IS (14, maybe using a 14 x 16 grid) would have been more elegant an entry, but adding more theme material will almost always make the construction harder. Plus, a seven-letter entry like DOTTED I can go right in the middle without causing construction problems. Notice how HOE and REA (instead of banks of black squares) flank DOTTED I? That means the sides of the grid can be broken up in many, many different ways. A 9 or 11 or 13-letter revealer in the dead center makes construction more difficult, because it places a few black squares automatically
The fill is nice and smooth, although more marquee long fill would have been nice. Almost all the longest answers (all eight letters long) are single words, and aren't super snazzy. "Speaker's aid" helps to make ANECDOTE a better answer, and "Passed on, in a way" does the same for REPEATED — that sort of misdirection could have helped spice up the other eight-letter fill too.
And saving the best for last: "What some waiters never see?" as in "Waiting for GODOT"; that's absolutely brilliant cluing. More of that, please!