See the 22 answer words debuted by Matt Skoczen.
R | I | G | C | L | I | M | B | S | A | L | U | D | ||
A | A | R | E | E | L | E | R | A | T | O | N | E | ||
N | C | O | R | A | I | S | E | U | T | T | E | R | ||
D | O | W | N | T | H | E | H | A | T | C | H | |||
A | C | T | I | K | E | Y | E | D | U | P | ||||
L | C | H | A | I | M | S | T | A | T | O | F | U | ||
L | A | S | P | E | S | C | I | L | O | G | O | N | ||
B | O | T | T | O | M | S | U | P | ||||||
B | R | O | O | D | A | R | E | A | S | P | E | A | ||
A | E | R | O | C | N | N | C | H | E | E | R | S | ||
G | O | E | S | M | A | D | S | L | I | P | ||||
T | O | Y | O | U | R | H | E | A | L | T | H | |||
A | L | I | E | N | U | N | I | O | N | E | R | A | ||
G | E | N | R | E | T | I | P | P | I | T | E | L | ||
T | O | A | S | T | S | T | E | E | D | S | A | T |
Matt:
Initially, I had difficulty squeezing in all the theme entries (I think I had an initial number of eight plus the entry "toast"). I was going crazy thinking I couldn't get all eight in because I was just not good at construction — even after all the years I've been off-and-on constructing. I needed Vic to slap me in the face and let me know that eight themes plus a reveal is a daunting task, even for veterans. I think I was initially writing Vic about something else when I figured I should ask for help on that theme.
I so appreciate the help Vic offered and working with him. His style of collaborating is much more methodical and different (which is NOT a negative commentary) than others I have worked with or have tried to work with in collaborations and that number has been few anyway.
I have no idea where the TOAST theme came from; it has been a while. I'd say 90% of my themes, however, come from an idea that was originally something else but developed into the final puzzle. So, TOAST may likely have started out as anything referring to HATCHES or BURNT FOODS, but the final version is what came to fruition over the then-theme development progress. For another example, I once had a 21x21 (one about anniversaries published some time ago by Rich at LAT) come out of a 15x15 because I liked a theme entry that I came up with, but, of course, the entry was longer than 15 letters.
I do like the [Oktoberfest exclamation] repeat clue idea that Will decided on, especially since he chose it for an October puzzle.
Vic:
Matt, with whom I'd had the pleasure of collaborating back in 2009 or 2010 — we had a joint byline on a Sunday Los Angeles Times puzzle called "Where the Wild Things Are" — contacted me in November 2012 with an ambitious theme: eight theme answers, 58 letters, and every answer was a toast, except for TOAST, the designated reveal. I think Matt's message to me was two-fold: (1) Would you like to help? (2) If so, I'll share the credit.
The deal looked doable to me. We brainstormed back and forth for a few days. I constructed the grid; we contributed 50-50 to the fill and the cluing. The puzzle was submitted Dec. 9, 2012.
From the outset, we were of the mind that, with short and long theme answers, this theme needed to be 100% horizontal in the grid. I think I came up with the theme cluing scheme "Word/words after a shot," since I'd had some success with repeating-clue themes before (see Feb. 19, 2008; Aug. 13, 2008; Sept. 25, 2008; and Sept. 30, 2010). Clever of Will to change that to "Oktoberfest exclamation." But then, he's a clever guy.
M | A | S | T | E | R | I | C | U | S | O | P | T | D | R | A | K | E | |||
O | C | T | A | N | E | S | P | R | A | I | N | E | D | R | E | L | E | T | ||
S | H | A | L | L | O | W | B | U | S | I | N | E | S | S | I | D | L | E | S | |
E | O | N | P | A | N | A | N | D | I | E | U | P | D | O | S | |||||
Y | O | D | E | L | E | R | T | I | N | T | E | R | A | W | H | O | ||||
D | O | N | T | H | A | V | E | A | C | A | L | L | O | W | M | A | N | |||
S | C | A | G | G | S | U | P | I | H | S | I | A | N | E | N | T | ||||
C | E | R | E | S | A | L | P | A | C | A | H | S | T | |||||||
A | C | T | S | O | B | A | L | L | A | D | M | O | U | T | H | I | N | G | ||
R | E | F | N | A | B | R | I | S | E | E | S | P | I | E | S | |||||
F | L | I | T | W | A | L | L | E | T | N | U | R | S | E | S | R | T | A | ||
S | I | L | I | C | A | E | T | Y | M | U | P | N | V | A | L | |||||
A | M | E | R | I | C | A | S | C | A | L | L | U | P | O | R | A | T | E | ||
E | T | A | K | N | E | E | L | S | P | A | N | A | M | |||||||
M | E | A | D | E | R | T | S | N | N | E | G | R | O | A | N | S | ||||
I | M | D | A | L | L | Y | I | N | G | T | O | S | E | E | Y | O | U | |||
G | A | M | Y | O | S | C | A | R | S | E | M | B | L | E | M | S | ||||
N | I | G | E | L | T | R | I | T | T | M | O | C | P | E | A | |||||
C | U | R | A | D | B | A | L | L | R | O | O | M | C | L | O | S | E | T | S | |
S | E | E | M | E | S | C | A | L | A | B | L | E | U | N | S | E | R | S | ||
A | L | D | E | N | A | S | T | P | E | D | S | B | A | S | S | E | Y |
A | S | F | A | R | L | S | A | T | S | F | I | G | ||
L | A | R | G | O | E | P | C | O | T | I | R | A | ||
K | I | E | R | K | E | G | A | A | R | D | N | O | R | |
A | N | S | E | T | A | R | D | E | D | E | N | Y | ||
T | H | E | A | C | T | I | S | N | T | |||||
S | C | H | O | P | E | N | H | A | U | E | R | |||
S | M | O | T | E | R | O | T | E | N | C | O | |||
H | A | L | O | D | R | A | N | O | R | E | O | S | ||
A | M | Y | F | I | N | N | S | A | D | L | Y | |||
H | A | M | M | A | R | S | K | J | O | L | D | |||
P | E | N | T | E | R | R | A | T | A | |||||
T | W | I | N | P | L | A | T | S | R | A | R | E | ||
E | R | A | M | O | U | S | S | O | R | G | S | K | Y | |
R | A | D | G | O | A | P | E | O | U | T | I | E | ||
M | P | S | T | R | U | S | T | O | N | E | N | D |