B | L | A | S | T | S | E | R | E | C | T | ||||
A | L | A | S | K | A | N | G | E | T | O | U | T | ||
T | H | E | P | H | I | L | O | S | O | P | H | E | R | S |
B | O | S | S | R | E | B | A | T | E | D | N | A | ||
A | T | T | E | S | T | W | I | N | ||||||
A | S | P | S | S | T | A | L | L | S | |||||
A | S | L | A | N | E | T | A | T | K | E | E | N | ||
G | H | I | J | K | R | O | W | L | I | N | G | O | ||
A | U | R | A | L | E | N | O | E | N | D | O | W | ||
S | T | E | R | E | O | E | L | L | A | |||||
N | Y | E | A | P | P | L | E | T | ||||||
A | B | A | D | A | R | W | I | N | R | I | F | E | ||
D | A | N | I | E | L | R | A | D | C | L | I | F | F | E |
A | S | N | E | A | T | S | N | E | E | Z | E | S | ||
H | A | R | R | Y | P | O | T | T | E | R |
HARRY / POTTER! Hard to believe it's been 20 years since the initial (British) release. The series is a large part of why I started writing middle-grade books — my brother once said how sad he was, that there might never be anything as good as this series. I like me a challenge!
Speaking of a challenge, such a lot of thematic material packed in today. I enjoyed HARRY / POTTER snuck in at the very bottom, each word sneakily clued in non-Harry Potter ways.
AS NEAT (that feels too much like a verboten six-letter partial, BTW) as it was to get DANIEL RADCLIFFE over HARRY / POTTER, there were some trade-offs to make this work. Early-week puzzles usually depend on two sets of vertical black square bars on the bottom of a grid to make filling easier — having just one (between AS NEAT and SNEEZES) is a rough construction challenge. Besides AS NEAT, there's an IER and the odd EFFS.
That's not great, but not terrible either. I wouldn't have minded those prices to pay, except that there were already so many other gluey bits. I'm not sure why JK / ROW / LING gets split across the middle, but GHIJK is ... not good. That'd be a puzzle-killer for me. Along with AHOT, BLEST, ETH in the top of the grid, and a rough-for-newbies crossing in ASLAN / AGAS, it's too much for my taste.
I would have been fine with less thematic material, perhaps with THE PHILOSOPHERS / STONE intersecting smack dab in the middle, HARRY POTTER 11 and JKROWLING 9, using a mirror (left-right) grid layout.
The tough grid layout did allow for some nice bonuses like LOYALTY (Gryffindor!) and EGOTIST (Slytherin!). And ALASKAN got a great clue, "detached state" making me laugh.
As a huge fan, I like the 20-year tribute. But I wish it had been a smoother product for a Monday.
*Reparo!*
C | B | P | H | C | U | |||||||||
H | U | R | T | C | A | S | A | B | L | A | N | C | A | |
A | U | P | R | I | O | H | S | |||||||
L | A | N | C | A | S | T | E | R | C | R | A | S | H | |
E | E | N | H | R | E | |||||||||
T | I | T | A | N | I | C | F | R | E | E | M | A | N | |
E | U | R | E | |||||||||||
A | C | A | D | E | M | Y | A | W | A | R | D | S | ||
L | I | N | L | |||||||||||
P | L | A | T | O | O | N | C | H | I | C | A | G | O | |
S | N | S | B | N | A | |||||||||
H | A | N | K | S | G | L | A | D | I | A | T | O | R | |
A | I | E | I | T | S | H | I | |||||||
W | A | S | H | I | N | G | T | O | N | P | E | N | N | |
H | N | I | P | M | G |
C | O | V | E | R | B | A | N | J | O | I | S | T | ||
O | I | E | A | I | R | O | B | |||||||
P | R | O | T | E | A | N | C | E | C | I | L | I | A | |
L | L | D | D | E | H | T | S | |||||||
A | R | I | A | P | S | A | L | T | E | R | I | E | S | |
N | N | D | M | Y | S | E | ||||||||
D | R | I | V | E | L | E | D | S | T | A | G | E | S | |
S | V | N | C | R | U | |||||||||
T | I | T | L | E | S | S | O | N | A | T | I | N | A | |
A | L | U | M | L | T | L | ||||||||
B | O | S | T | O | N | P | O | P | S | L | A | M | P | |
O | E | P | B | O | C | R | H | |||||||
R | A | G | T | I | M | E | S | E | R | P | I | C | O | |
S | N | N | A | E | A | S | R | |||||||
S | O | N | G | S | T | E | R | B | A | T | O | N |
P | A | T | R | O | N | A | G | E | M | O | S | E | S | |
I | O | U | N | A | O | A | A | |||||||
C | O | U | R | T | E | D | S | E | N | A | T | O | R | |
A | C | B | Y | E | D | I | G | |||||||
S | C | H | O | O | L | F | L | O | R | E | N | C | E | |
S | E | X | D | I | N | |||||||||
O | U | S | T | M | A | R | T | I | A | L | A | R | T | |
U | P | L | A | N | D | |||||||||
P | O | P | A | R | T | I | S | T | S | G | O | Y | A | |
O | U | E | B | R | U | |||||||||
I | M | P | A | S | T | O | S | C | O | B | A | L | T | |
N | A | S | C | A | R | T | O | |||||||
T | A | R | N | I | S | H | D | A | D | A | I | S | M | |
E | E | A | E | A | E | O | A | |||||||
R | O | D | I | N | R | E | M | B | R | A | N | D | T |