P | A | W | P | R | I | N | T | S | M | A | P | S | ||
U | F | O | R | E | P | O | R | T | S | A | B | I | T | |
M | A | K | E | S | A | D | E | A | L | C | O | C | A | |
P | R | E | C | O | D | E | E | R | A | B | U | T | T | |
I | A | M | S | W | E | E | T | I | E | |||||
P | B | S | K | I | D | S | S | A | T | F | O | R | ||
C | L | U | E | N | U | U | K | T | H | A | N | E | ||
L | A | S | S | I | E | N | N | A | S | C | A | P | ||
A | N | D | R | A | S | U | E | D | H | E | R | S | ||
S | E | R | E | N | A | P | E | A | B | O | D | Y | ||
S | T | I | C | K | U | M | T | E | L | |||||
A | A | V | E | G | E | T | A | W | A | Y | C | A | R | |
C | R | E | D | U | R | A | N | I | U | M | O | R | E | |
T | I | R | E | R | I | C | K | S | T | E | V | E | S | |
S | A | S | S | T | H | A | T | S | N | E | A | T |
T | E | M | P | O | R | A | M | S | E | E | P | |||
K | A | R | A | T | J | O | K | E | U | L | N | A | ||
O | U | T | R | O | O | B | I | T | D | E | E | R | ||
T | H | I | S | O | N | E | S | O | N | M | E | |||
I | T | S | Y | T | E | C | O | K | A | Y | ||||
T | O | O | B | A | D | F | O | R | Y | O | U | |||
A | W | F | U | L | P | E | E | T | B | R | B | |||
L | E | T | S | L | I | P | A | S | H | T | R | A | Y | |
O | R | G | T | R | A | M | E | R | U | P | T | |||
S | H | A | L | L | W | E | D | A | N | C | E | |||
M | A | Y | A | B | O | A | S | O | D | S | ||||
P | A | S | S | T | H | E | T | O | R | C | H | |||
D | R | A | T | I | C | E | D | H | A | P | P | Y | ||
A | C | N | E | G | R | A | Y | I | R | A | T | E | ||
S | H | A | M | H | U | M | A | T | T | A | R |
I submitted this theme just a day or two before the Times ran an excellent Ross Trudeau puzzle with the revealer THIS TOO SHALL PASS — so I was initially quite doubtful it would be accepted. I hope enough time has passed since then that solvers are ready for a different take, and that this one feels fresh and sweet. The adage, I think, is at once timely and timeless.
If I were making this puzzle today, I would choose different fill for the upper middle region of the grid; the pileup of proper names in this version — in particular the TEC/JOSEF and PEET/REA crossings — seems far from ideal, especially for a Monday. I will also have to hope that my clue for PARTY BUS [Vehicle you can raise the roof on?] finds another home somewhere down the line.
D | O | G | L | E | G | J | A | R | A | P | P | |||
O | O | L | A | L | A | G | U | S | H | O | V | E | R | |
O | Z | A | R | K | S | S | I | S | E | N | O | R | A | |
M | E | M | E | E | A | C | H | S | U | C | K | Y | ||
I | T | S | W | A | R | U | S | A | ||||||
Y | E | R | A | L | O | E | S | I | M | O | ||||
X | O | X | O | Y | E | W | S | T | O | A | D | |||
L | O | U | A | N | N | C | R | O | A | K | S | |||
O | U | I | S | O | P | A | L | O | R | S | O | |||
N | T | H | G | N | O | M | E | O | P | T | ||||
E | M | U | L | E | G | U | M | E | ||||||
L | O | M | A | N | K | N | O | B | I | H | O | P | ||
T | H | A | T | S | S | A | D | E | Q | U | A | T | E | |
D | O | T | T | H | E | I | S | R | U | B | S | O | N | |
S | H | H | Y | E | S | S | E | E | P | E | D |
Hello, puzzle people. I hope you've tolerated (maybe even enjoyed??) my first puzzle in the NYT. I live and work on a dairy farm in Western MA, and I also write publishable crosswords, apparently.
There's a lot I appreciate about this puzzle — the theme density, all of the animals that found their way into the grid, the shout-out — albeit indirect — to the USWNT. At the same time, my preferences and priorities as a constructor have evolved a lot since I wrote it, and I'd do some things differently if I were making it today. For starters, I would avoid the entry ODS (it could have been replaced here with STY, something I realized a bit too late). I'd also consider sacrificing a theme answer in exchange for a grid with fewer black squares and/or a substitute for POLKA DOTS that better conceals the string DOT.
Three things, in particular, made this grid a tough one to put together:
With all of those constraints, I'm happy things worked out as cleanly as they did.
I'll leave y'all with a few clues of mine that didn't make it into the final version:
Happy solving :)