Complete fail at "Name that Theme" today. Should I be embarrassed, since I couldn't figure out the theme while solving, even though I ...
read moreComplete fail at "Name that Theme" today. Should I be embarrassed, since I couldn't figure out the theme while solving, even though I was raised in CALIFORNIA? Or is shameful more accurate, given that it took me a full minute after hitting CALIFORNIA to understand the theme — and that I lived in SAN Jose for two decades?
Let's go with shame.
Will Shortz often shies away from name-heavy themes, since they can come across as more of a trivia contest than a word puzzle. Knowing only 1.5 of the featured people (partial credit for identifying DIEGO RIVERA, but only after giving DIEGO MARADONA some serious thought), I had a hard time with the solve.
I had some fun brainstorming other people that might have been more familiar. For JOSE, I'd have gone with JOSE CUERVO. As a longtime Oakland A's fan, I like JOSE CANSECO, but I'm not sure how much he's faded out of the limelight.
FRANCISCO and DIEGO are tougher. I'd probably go with FRANCISCO GOYA. FRANCISCO PIZARRO is likely more recognizable, but there is the little matter of all his mass murder.
I wonder if the most appropriate word is "humiliated," since I couldn't figure out that SAN RAFAEL was a city in CALIFORNIA — one that's about two hours from where I grew up. Everyone pronounces it "San Ra-fel," which is different than "Ra-phai-el Nadal." That's my excuse, and I'm sticking to it.
In a puzzle featuring names in the theme, it's best to go easy on the names in the fill. Avoiding some of ALCOA / LYONS / SARDI — that last one crossing the kooky FARO and OSE, no bueno! — would have been better. I enjoyed the BENGALI BATCAVE FAR LEFT bonuses, but I'd have liked a round of revision to smooth out ASALE AERO OSE SALA as well.
All in all, though, a strong theme concept leading to a fun a-ha moment (that this CALIFORNIAn should have known from the get-go, fine!).