Fun pre-Thanksgiving puzzle from Jules, phrases containing a hidden traditional Thanksgiving dish. If only there were such a thing as ...
read moreFun pre-Thanksgiving puzzle from Jules, phrases containing a hidden traditional Thanksgiving dish. If only there were such a thing as BRUSSEL SPROUT FLAIR or PECAN PIE GEOGRAPHY so my favorite American Thanksgiving foods could have been included*.
Well-constructed puzzle. Five is becoming the new four in terms of theme entries, and it's hard to pull off cleanly. Jules only has two long downs in the puzzle but makes good use of them: CHARLESTON and BUICK SEDAN are both quite nice. And it allows him to fill the puzzle cleanly, with just a smattering of ETTE, OTOS, A LOOP.
Sidebar on A LOOP: there's a surprising disparity among constructors on what the worst type of fill is. I would have guessed that everyone would have a similar hierarchy: old-timey entries like ADIT at the top of the hit list, followed by crossword-friendly words like ERNE/EPEE, esoteric names, and then partials. But it's been eye-opening working with a bevy of different collaborators. Some of them are completely fine with partials and some abhor them, especially five-letter ones. It sure would be nice to have one scale with which to judge what is "good" or "bad", but this serves as a good reminder that so much in crosswords is subjective.
I generally like to see a theme that is both consistent and specific, and this puzzle certainly hits on the former. One might think that it misses on specificity, since there are dozens of traditional Thanksgiving Day foods which could be included. But how many can be hidden within phrases, where the food doesn't mean the food? I couldn't think of any right off the top. So well done there.
This puzzle has made me hungry. Off to fetch my eating pants!
*Food donations can be sent via fax and/or modem to www.xwordinfo.com; just shove it into your USB port and hit "enter".