I love variety in most areas of my life, including crosswords. The first thing I check in a crossword is the byline. I really enjoy ...
read moreI love variety in most areas of my life, including crosswords. The first thing I check in a crossword is the byline. I really enjoy seeing work from hundreds of different people, being exposed to different perspectives, ideas and clues. I rarely enjoy seeing too many puzzles from one person, because it can feel like too much of the same flavor. But I would gladly take a PB themeless puzzle two or three times a month, possibly more.
What first drew my attention today was the big L-sections of white space in the NE and SW. Triple-stacks of 8-10 letter entries are hard enough to do when cordoned off from the rest of the grid, but when they turn the corner like this, intersecting ANOTHER stack of long answers, that gets very, very difficult to construct cleanly. Most of the time with this sort of arrangement you'll see a smattering of ugly entries which help hold the grid together. Not so today. Clean stuff all around; masterful.
Those corners are noticeably un-Scrabbly, just a K and V in total (in the heart of those sections), but note how well Patrick has chosen his entries to snazz up those regions up. The bottom is beautiful, HOT POTATO atop ONION RING atop WET PAINT. And CAT CHOW and ILL GET IT crossing that stack! One of my favorite corners from recent memory. The top is nice too, although RETRIEVER and RECEIVER give it a bit more workmanlike quality.
In the NW, I loved BASQUE and QADDAFI but had trouble recalling OXNARD even though I grew up in California. Not knowing AXTON made it extremely tough; a lucky guess. Having URI and ONE AM up there felt not quite as clean as the usual Berry fare, too. Minor points though, compared to the excellence of the whole.
Finally, kudos for the cluing. I always know I'm going to get an entertaining workout with a PB themeless, because the clues are so well done. "On-deck circle?" = fantastic clue for a fantastic answer. And I loved the "Unwelcome benchmark?" and WET PAINT pair.
More please!